May 31, 2010
Kim Smith - Joe's Pub - May 30, 2010
The show opened up with Jerry Steichen on piano. As Steichen played, the shows opening prelude “Morphium,” cellist Saeunn Thorsteindottir leaned against the stage entrance with her left hand strategically placed against the wall. When it came time to play her part, Thorsteindottir walked a short distance to her cello and began to play. The intriguing prelude“Morphium” was very film noir which is not surprising. The writer was Misha Spivakovsky who did many Hollywood film scores after leaving Berlin in 1933.
Pianist Steichen later stopped by my table alluding to German dancer and prostitute, Anita Berber who performed her "Cocaine" dance to “Morphium” in one of her shows at the Weisse Maus cabaret in the 1920's Berlin. The story goes that some of Beber's performances of the “Morphium” dance showed a little too much skin. So much so, that the club patrons wore masks to protect their identity. Ironically, Berber died young from an alcohol and cocaine overdose.
For me, Kim Smith's show started with the next two songs. The first dramatically described a man who was so beautiful that everyone wanted him. The lyric included lines like “Women formed a choir around him.” Smith seamlessly segued into “You Keep Me Hangin' On.” I've heard the song stand-up to many arrangements, from the Supremes to The Vanilla Fudge. Smith used the song, moving from the objective to the personal, keeping it in the feel of the Weimar Era by doing it in 3/4 timing instead of 4/4. The song held up to Kim Smith's arrangement as well.
Before moving onto the next song, Smith spoke to the audience while remaining in character. He introduced the Steichen on piano, but when he introduced Thorsteindottir he humorously said “She's the muscle of the organization.” Smith kept the audience chuckling by telling us about Kim Wilde; the British pop star, who also performed “You Keep Me Hangin' On.,” in the 80's. (Her other big hit was “Kids In America"). He said Kim Wilde was her stage name; her real name was Kim Smith. Mr.Smith found out the information regarding Wilde's real name when he googled himself to see if someone had made up a wikipedia page of him.
Smith set up the next song by saying he had to sell himself then moved into the audience putting his hands on men's shoulders as he sauntered around the room. What Smith did, did not read as if he were selling himself. Selling one's self would be sitting on a man's lap, sipping his martini, ruffling his hair or holding his chin and looking into his eyes. (Note to Smith: See Ute Lemper the next time she performs.) I'm sure doing all I just described might have made a few men in the audience uncomfortable, but I felt what Smith did was play it too safe. From where I sit, if a performer is going to walk through the audience, he better interact with them. Otherwise, it comes off as pretentious.
The following three songs had to do with being incurably romantic and long lost love. When Smith got to the second song “Once Upon a Summertime,” I wrote in my notes – too studied. During the ballad, there was a moment when Smith kept his hands by his side. It was the one moment when I was actually feeling something during Kim Smith's performance. That moment came and went almost as quickly as a 15 second TV commercial.
Before doing the song medley “Drunken Sailor/Pirate Jenny,” Smith told someone in the audience “don't get drunk because we won't know what to do with you.” He then sang the song which asked what to do with a drunken sailor. Both songs in the medley were sang from a female perspective. (Did he think any sailors would be in the audience due to the memorial day weekend?....hmm)
Smith ended his show with a group of 4 songs which he dubbed the “Optimistic Suite.” The suite started with “Optomistic Voices” and ended with “Over the Rainbow” in German. Both songs were from, of course,The Wizard of Oz. The suite was pretty good but didn't feel like the grand finale it was supposed to be.
I would like to say that Kim Smith came back for an encore but he never left the stage. It was very clear that the encore was written as a definite part of the show, not as a maybe. Smith did his other signature song, “Missed Me,” and then tagged the show with a song snippet as he walked off into the audience from whence he came.
I think Kim Smith is extremely talented. What disappointed me about Smith's show is I don't feel like I really got to know Kim Smith through his character. Kim Smith's performance was at Joe's Pub in 21st Century New York City not 1920's Germany. I would have liked to have seen Kim Smith embody that German character while living inside Joe's Pub not inside an imaginary theater with a forth wall.
Jerry Steichen on piano
Saeunn Thorsteindottir on Cello
Kim Smith on Vocals
Kim Smith's Set List
Morphium (Misha Spoliansky, 1920)
Nature Boy (Eden Abba, 1948)
Jonny, Wenn Du Geburtstag Hast? (Fredrich Hollaender, 1920)
You Keep Me Hangin' On' (Holland/ Dozier/Holland, 1966)
Black Market (Friedrich Hollaender, 1939)
Song of Black Max (Bolcom/Weinstein, 1977)
Hôtel (Franics Poulenc, 1940)
Once Upon A Summertime (Mercer/Baraclay/LeGrand, 1954)
Peter, Peter (Rudolph Nelson, 1929)
Dance Only With Me (Styne/Comden/Gree, 1958)
Drunken Sailor/ Pirate Jenny (Weill, 1928)
-Optomistic Voices (Arlen/Stothart/Harburg, 1939)
-Here I'll Stay/ Morphium (Weil/Lerner, 1948)
-Munchhausen (Friedrich Hollaender, 1930)
-Wenn Du In Meinen Traumen (Over the Rainbow) (Arlen/Harburg, 1939)
Missed Me (Amanda Palmer, 1998)
And The Are Dark And Fearful ( Eisler/Brecht, 1945)
Special Thanks to Robert Y. Chang for all the color photos in this posting.